I was accosted by a huge sale bin of these attractively packaged cookie bars on the way in to the grocery store the other day. I was feeling a bit under the weather – so a comfort food impulse purchase seemed entirely within bounds – and they ended up in the bag with some jarred hot and sour soup and frozen garlic bread. I mustered the restraint necessary to wait until dessert before opening them.
While not tasting exactly like chocolate chip cookies, they do, to my recollection, share a flavour profile with a favourite lost cookie from my childhood: Nabisco Hoo-Rays. They’re missing the caramel, but the preponderance of toasted coconut, chocolate and biscuit paint as complete a picture as I need for a cookie that I haven’t eaten in over 25 years. Yes, I looked that up.
I’ve researched these guys in the past, but came up pretty much empty-handed. Finally though, it seems the information has caught up with my need to know. Hoo-Rays were rectangular and came in a paper bag, and they were quite similar to Chew-Chews, which were ring-shaped and lived in a cello-tray affair. A forum query a while back got a response suggesting a similarity to Girl Scout S’Mores, which made no sense to me until I discovered today the existence of the Girl Scout Samoa Cookie.
Now I’ve never seen a Girl Scout hawking a Samoa Cookie before, and it may be a regional thing; up here you get two flavours of fairly run-of-the-mill sandwich cookies, which you buy from co-workers almost entirely out of charity. Maybe they have some kind of minty offering too – I’ve been out of the office environment for a while and no one has come do my door with cookies in hand. If you have a Girl Scout troop around here, tell your girls to step it up.
So there you have it; not exactly Proust, but more information that wants to be free. Suggested pairing with Girl Scout Samoa Cookies: Sauternes. Also, in somewhat obvious revelations, NAtional BIScuit COmpany = NABISCO. Dur.
Keebler makes a cookie, Coconut Dreams, that’s identical to the Girl Scout Samoa. It’s got chocolate, coconut, and caramel, and seems to be the same as the Chew-Chews you mentioned. I don’t remember Hoo-Rays, though.
Very interesting. According to Wikipedia, “Keebler-Wyl Bakery became the official baker of Girl Scout Cookies in 1936, the first commercial company to bake the cookies,” which may explain the connection. Sadly, however, Keebler cookies are not sold in Canada as far as I know.
I am SO glad someone else remembers them. They were THE BEST.